I was told that its good to know about PAST,but we
should focus more towards the FUTURE...
Political and Religious views,values or issues will not feed your
family or pay your mortgage...This generation or the next,

I guess by doing this will keep you n your family happy....

The documentary does not do justice to Jarnail Singh. She interviews Mark Tully and Brar but for view of Jarnail Singh only a young man is interviewed. The translation of Pooran Singh's statements do not convey his correct feelings. She should have interviewed Gurtej Singh or Dalbeer Singh who were closely associated with Baba Jarnail Singh to get his side of the story.
The documentary does catch the pain of Nov 84 sikh genocide tragedy but ignores to mention the names of Tytler, Bhagat, Sajjan kumar etc as the instigators.
Overall does not do justice to the sikh movement.

Sonia, an excellent exposition. For a young person born/raised in West to gather information and inform the world is outstanding. Re. Brar's comments “Bhindernwala may have started as a saint but definitely did not die as a saint” he is missing his own roots. He thinks that saints are expected only to sacrifice themselves like 5th and 9th guru. He forgets saint/soldier concept; he also forgets he rose to army ranks because of "singh" spirit in him & he calls himself Kuldip "Singh" because “singh” name brought him where he was on day of attack. You mentioned close interaction between hindus and sikhs during Dewali. Such interactions existed before the attack as well. It will be wrong to blame all hindus for these atrocities. The attack was politically motivated & brutalities were carried out by thugs that had significant political influence/connections. The regret that still remains is the lack of justice for all those innocent victims.

The Hindu code of Law defying the very existence of Sikhs and all minorities including Buddhist still exist. As per Indian Legislation Sikhs have no right to exist.
The very BBC had a very different story on Nov1 On 1984.

Again the same old cheap game attack from within and it will easy to twist it and make it well accepted.
Why "Phoolka" why not a independent board , why not Amnesty, why not A independent Human rights body well funded. Sikhs have to think and think hard?? What did we achieve after 25 years KamalNath clearly involved still sitting in power??
Moral:
Another diminishing hammer at the end. If you the host miss Weak. that is what you are in person why you have to present it on as if it was us. We are living practicing Sikhs in West. Please keep Your BS to your personnel self. But again every thing is for sale with some ppl otherwise thousands of victims would not have been denied Justice.

This documentary documents and describes the unfortunate period in Sikh history and politics of Punjab in a very truthful and balanced way. A must see by all people, not just by Sikhs.